Our Menu
Appetizers
Garlic Bread with Cheese
$7.99
Served with marinara.
Chicken Bites
$9.99/12 Pieces
White chicken lightly breaded fried golden brown. Served with a sauce of your choice.
Pretzel Bites
$7.99/14 Pieces
A basket of deep fried pretzel nuggets. Served with honey mustard | Add Cheese Dip +$1.50
Homemade Cheese Balls
$10.99/6 Pieces
Pepperoni and mozzarella cheese hand rolled, lightly breaded, and deep fried. Served with marinara.
Toasted Raviolis
$10.99/8 Pieces
Crisp, golden brown cheese-filled raviolis dusted with parmesan cheese. Served with marinara.
Homemade Potato Skins
$10.99/3 Pieces
Jumbo potato skins topped with melted cheddar jack cheese and freshly crumbled bacon. Served with sour cream.
Salads
Salad Dressings: Ranch | Blue Cheese | Caesar | Honey Mustard | Grandma's Italian | Sarah's Sweet Red French • Add Chicken to Salads +$5.99
Garden Salad
$8.99/+
Iceberg lettuce, tomato, red onion, green peppers, pepperoni, provolone cheese, banana peppers and black olives • Small $8.99 | Large $12.99
Caesar Salad
$8.99/+
Crisp romaine with authentic house-made Caesar dressing, our own Gatsby’s pizza crust seasoned croutons. Topped with shaved parmesean • Small $8.99 | Large $12.99
Pizza
Toppings: Pepperoni | Sausage | Bacon | Ham | Homemade Meatballs | Chicken | Anchovy | Pineapple | Fresh Mushroom | Onion | Tomato | Green Pepper | Banana Pepper | Black Olives | Jalapeno | Green Olives | Fresh Basil | Vegan Cheese • You can always order our pizzas half baked, no cut. To reheat later in your air fryer, on your grill, or in your oven!
BYO Small Cheese
$14.25/10”
With pizza sauce and cheese.
BYO Large Cheese
$17.25/14”
With pizza sauce and cheese.
Half Pizza
$1.50/Veggies
$1.75/Meat
Whole Pizza
$2.00/Veggies
$2.25/Meat
SPECIALTY PIZZA:
Margherita
$14.99/10"
$19.99/14"
Mozzarella and provolone blended cheese, tomatoes, fresh basil, garlic, and olive oil.
Ranch Chicken
$17.99/10"
$22.99/14"
Blended cheese, marinated chicken, and specialty ranch.
Bleu Chicken
$19.99/10"
$24.99/14"
Tangy bleu cheese dressing, mozzarella cheese, grilled chicken, onions and green olives.
Buckeye Favorite
$19.99/10"
$24.99/14"
Pepperoni, sausage, capicola ham, banana peppers and black olives.
Cauliflower Crust with Cheese
$17.25/10"
Toppings: Half $1.50 | Whole $1.75
5 ITEM SPECIAL:
10” Pizza
$19.99
Pick any 5 items.
14” Pizza
$24.25
Pick any 5 items.
Subs
All subs include chips & a pickle.
Gatsby's Sub
$10.99/+
Ham, salami, capicola ham, and smoked provolone on an 10" Italian sub bun. This world famous sandwich is oven-heated and topped with lettuce, tomato, banana peppers and our special dressing • Half $10.99 | Full $12.99
Meatball Sub
$12.99
Homemade meatballs topped with marinara and smoked provolone oven baked on an 10" Italian sub bun.
Chicken Parmesan Sub
$12.99
Homemade seasoned chicken breast topped with marinara and smoked provolone on an 10” Italian sub bun.
Veggie Sub
$11.99
Mushrooms, black olives, green peppers, onions, banana peppers, and smoked provolone layered into an 10” Italian sub bun and oven-heated. Topped with lettuce, tomato and our special dressing.
Sides
Homemade Coleslaw
$3.99
The best in town.
Hand - Cut Fries
$5.99/+
Side $5.99 | Basket $6.99 • Add Cheese Dip +$1.50
Desserts
Key Lime Pie
$8.00
Homemade Cannoli
$8.00
Salted Carmel Cheescake
$9.00