Order Online
Pick up your favorite food
Don't feel like cooking today? We got you covered - order now!
About Us
Delicious pizza....Mouth watering
Great recipes and tastes you love and expect, that is uniquely Gatsbys Pizza! Check out our expanded menu which includes appetizers, subs, hand-cut fries, homemade coleslaw and salad dressings, desserts, and beer and wine
Groups & Parties
Book your next party with us!
Come to celebrate your special event or - give us the opportunity to make your event memorable. We look forward to serving and seeing you soon!
Book now a private party
Eat. Drink. Enjoy.
Proud To Be Authentic
Hand-spun
Take us home with you!
Great outside patio
Specials
We are updating our specials
Please stay tuned
Reviews
Review by - Google
Erin O:
Not only is the pizza so delicious (thin crust, but soft and crispy, the sauce was perfection, and the pepperoni/sausage, mushrooms/onions were so fresh and tasty), the inside is super cute too, even the bathroom was cool! Also, the owners are two of the sweetest, friendliest people I have ever met! I could have chatted with them for hours! I will definitely be back-highly recommended!
Review by - Google
Sandra S:
Delicious!! The homemade cheese balls were wonderful. The crust was thin and not greasy at all!!
Review by - Google
Cris:
What a great spot! We ordered a pizza and some cheesy garlic bread for takeout, and it was ready super fast. The pizza was delicious, with crispy crust and plenty of cheese and the garlic bread had extra sauce for dipping. The staff was SO kind and went out of their way to accommodate us, and I wish we would have found this place sooner during our trip. The inside is really cute - I love their decorations. If you're going to get the garlic bread, definitely get it with cheese! You won't regret it.
Review by - Google
Jenna W:
I saw someone post on Facebook about this place and wanted to give it a try! The lady that worked there was super friendly (owner). Think it is a husband and wife that runs the restaurant. Go Buckeyes! They are from Ohio which I am too! The pizza was really good. Each slice had a good crunch to it and loved the taste. I like how it is cut into tiny squares and is thin sliced.
Review by - Google
Brooke P:
So so so good!!!!! I am thrilled that Bonita Springs finally has an even better Gatsbys Pizza then the previous one, that was fabulous, but this... Oh my goodness! The pretzel bites and beer cheese, so good and the Pizza, well, it doesn't get better than this!!! Yummy!!!
Newsletter
Location
28811 South Tamiami Trail, Suite 5
Bonita Springs, FL
34134
Hours
PERMANENTLY CLOSED!
